A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF RUMS ON THE BASIS OF HALIDE EDIP ADIVAR’S NOVELS AND HER MEMOIRS
Journal Title: The Journal of International Social Research - Year 2016, Vol 9, Issue 47
Abstract
Literary texts help the understanding of social structure. We can find the interests of society and individual in fictive works such as novel and story as well as memoirs. Even memoirs are more realistic in the context of place, time and person compare to novel and story. They present the told period, event or the person in a more realistic and detailed way. This paper compares the Halide Edip Adıvar’s perspective on Rums by analyzing her memoirs Mor Salkımlı Ev and Türk’ün Ateşle İmtihanı and her novels Ateşten Gömlek, Vurun Kahpeye, and Yeni Turan. The Rums whom Halide Edip Adıvar mentions in her memoirs and the Rums whom she characterizes in her fiction are quite different. The Rums in Ateşten Gömlek are enemies; some of the main characters of the novel; Ayşe’s husband and her son are killed by Rums in the occupation of İzmir. While the Rums in the novel are ‘others’ and tyrants, the Rums in Mor Salkımlı Ev are different. For example Halide Edip’s ‘the deepest and the longest love’ is her old nursemaid Kiria Eleni. Halide Edip always remembers that her Rum neighbors gives her candy. She does not feel alienated in İskenderiye as she can speak Greek from her early childhood. When she was away from her family and was all alone in İskenderiye, she got the greatest support from a Rum doctor who was benevolent, merciful and kind old man. Halide Edip whose nursemaid was a Rum also hires a Rum nursemaid for her children. She entrusts a rum girl to her little boy. Ateşten Gömlek was published for the first time in 1922 when the bloody memoirs of Turkish War of Independence were fresh. The newly established State of the Republic of Turkey is a nation state and the ‘other’ of the independence war is Rums. The killer and cruel Rum characters in Ateşten Gömlek which can be classified as a thesis novel are depicted in accordance with this perspective. On the other hand the Turkish version of the Mor Salkımlı Ev was published for the first time in 1963. In Mor Salkımlı Ev which was published after 40 years of the publication of the Ateşten Gömlek, Halide Edip tells her memoirs from her early childhood to the year of 1918. While she depicts her Rum neighbors, nursemaid in a more humanitarian perspective in her memoirs, she changes this perspective when she writes a thesis novel. Consequently, this paper analysis the Halide Edip Adıvar’s perspective on Rums on the basis of this difference. The perception of Rum is not only limited to the Ateşten Gömlek. This situation can be observed in many of her stories primarily such as Yeni Turan. Thus, when this paper analyzes the Halide Edip Adıvar’s envision about Rums, it partly refers to these stories as well. The second subject analyzed and questioned in the article is why not Halide Edip is not classified as one of the Anatolian nationalists according to the Herkül Milas’s classification.
Authors and Affiliations
Ensar KESEBİR
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP252754
- DOI 10.17719/jisr.2016.1362
- Views 124
- Downloads 0
PRE-COLONIAL WEST AFRICAN DIPLOMACY: IT’S NATURE AND IMPACT
The neglect, for a long time, of African diplomatic history particularly, by scholars of African history, and the failure to forcefully project the history and image of Africa, exposed the continent to uncharitable, disp...
A JOURNAL IN BURSA: VOICE OF WOMEN POETS IN NİLÜFER
Nilüfer which is published from 1886 to 1891 is the first literature and art jaurnal in Bursa. Owner of the jaurnal is Feraizcizâde Mehmet Şâkir. In addition to articles about hard science religious and litarature articl...
INVESTIGATION OF 6th GRADE STUDENTS’ LEVEL OF ACHIEVEMENT ON THE PRODUCTION, DISTRIBUTION, AND CONSUMPTİON LEARNING SPACE IN SOCIAL STUDIES IN TERMS OF VARIOUS VARIABLES
The purpose of this research is to determine what level of students' academic achievement is, in terms of different variables, in the learning areas of Production, Distribution and Consumption that is located in the sixt...
TEXTUAL HYBRIDITY IN CONTEMPORARY FRENCH THEATER
This article deals with the changes the modern French drama has experienced up until today. It presents and discusses different play examples within the changing process. Starting from the 1980’s, contemporary french th...
A HERMIT: A KIERKEGAARDIAN READING OF GEORGE ELIOT’S SILAS MARNER
The present article aims to examine George Eliot’s Silas Marner through the lens of Kierkegaard’s notion of three spheres of existence. Soren Kierkeggard as theistic existentialist, reshaped existential notions in the f...