A Philosophy of Mind Evaluation on Soul-Body Dualism in Avicenna’s Metaphysics
Journal Title: İlahiyat Tetkikleri Dergisi - Year 2018, Vol 1, Issue 49
Abstract
Soul has been a huge problem in history of philosophy within the context of its description, existence, immortality and its relationship with body since the ancient times. Avicenna’s theory on soul could be evaluated as a bridge between his epistemological and ontological ideas. Although his theory has similar characteristics with Plato’s and Aristoteles’ philosophical arguments on soul, Avicenna offers a significant schema on soul that really exceeds both Plato and Aristoteles. Avicenna proposed a systematical analysis of mind-body problem decades before Descartes, who has been known as the constructer of mind-body problem. Therefore, it should be taken into an account that Avicenna although lived in Middle-ages, made a significant contribution to both psychology and philosophy of mind indirectly. The aim of this essay is firstly to evaluate Avicenna’s soul theory concerning the description of soul, the nature of soul, types of soul and the functions of soul and then to search for its effects on modern philosophy of mind. Especially it is easy to realize that there is an explicit similarity between Descartes and Avicenna’s ideas on soul. On the issue of mind-body problem, Descartes claims that mind could exist without the existence of body. Mind is a separate and distinct substance; however, there is a mutual relationship between mind and body through pineal gland. Similar with Descartes, Avicenna also claims that soul can exist without body because it is a distinct substance. He constructs a ground for this idea by using his popular thought experiment “flyman”. In this essay, it is tried to be indicated that Avicenna’s theory of soul has important reflections both on Descartes and modern philosophy of mind
Authors and Affiliations
Mehtap DOĞAN
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP516277
- DOI -
- Views 131
- Downloads 0
An Evaluation About the Number and Order of the Children Born from Khadija of The Prophet’s
In resources, there is little report about the Prophet’s children, who were born by Khadijah. However there can be observed differences in the information given by these resources about the number of the children and the...
Abul Hasan al-Lahmî and His Significance in the Malikî Sect
The Maliki Sect emerged in result of Imam Malik (d. 179/795) and his students’ fiqhi (Islamic jurisprudential) activities split into various schools such as Egypt, Kairawan, Madina, Andalus, and Iraq due to either geogra...
The Criticisims of Samîn al-Halabî against to Raghib in terms of Gharib al-Qur’an’s Method
This article is the product of a comparative study of two Qur’anic dictionaries. The first one is the work of Raghib al-Isfahani titled al-Mufradat. The other is the work titled Umdah al-huffaz by Samîn al-Halabî who l...
The Approach of Terzi Baba on Some Sufi Concepts in His Work “Kenzu’l-Miftâh”
Muhammed Vehbi, also known as Terzi Baba, lived in XIX. century. He devoted himself to Mawlânâ Khâleed al-Baghdâdî (d. 1242/1827), the founder of the Halidiyye branch of the Naqshbandi cult through ‘Abdullah Makkî, and...
Mahmut Kelpeten, Pre-Islamic South and North Arabia, Kuramer Pub., Istanbul, 2016
In our work, Pre-Islamic South and North Arabia wrinting by Mahmut Kelpetin is presented.