An Analysis of the Non-distinction between Weakness of Will and Compulsion: With a Discussion on Its Application in Medical Practice
Journal Title: Medicine and Philosophy - Year 2024, Vol 45, Issue 22
Abstract
Research on the moral attribution of weakness of will and compulsion primarily encompasses the standard view, the identificationist view, and the revisionism. The standard view posits that an individual's control over desires is the core distinction between the two, while the identificationist view use the degree of identification with desires as the criterion. However, both perspectives are grounded in the backward-looking approach and thus fail to effectively address the distinction between weakness of will and compulsion. Revisionism, by challenging the standard and the identification view and adopting the forward-looking approach, suggests that individuals may still bear moral responsibility even when actions stem from compulsion, thereby eliminating the boundary between the two. Compared to other perspectives, revisionism presents distinct advantages and is better suited for application in medical practice.
Authors and Affiliations
Yang LIU,Zining ZHANG,
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP758799
- DOI -
- Views 34
- Downloads 0
Health Ethics, Practical Challenges and Mechanism Improvement of Family Doctor Service System
Humanistic care, the spirit of the contract and resource allocation are the core orientations of health ethics in the family doctor service system. However, there are many practical challenges of health ethics in the pra...
The Economic Pressure and Coping Strategies of Rural Infertile Women Undergoing Assisted Reproductive Technologies Treatments
Based on a process-oriented perspective, this paper discusses the economic pressure and coping strategies of the rural infertile women in Guangxi undergoing assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs) treatments from three...
Clarifying the Relationship between Mental Disorders through the "Mental Level Table"
Current diagnostic systems of mental disorders have some defects, such as the lack of logic in the order and many differences between categories. A foundational framework is needed to interconnect various mental disorder...
Legislative Construction of Confidentiality Exemption Rules in Psychological Counseling
The paper discusses the legislative construction of confidentiality exemption rules in psychological counseling, particularly in the context of "Mental Health Law of the People's Republic of China". This law sets foundat...
The Ethical Challenge and Governance Strategies of Artificial Intelligence in Personalized Diabetes Treatment
The application of artificial intelligence (AI) in personalized diabetes treatment provides a better solution to ease the tension of medical resources in China, improve the efficiency of diagnosis and treatment of diabet...