ARE HUMAN RIGHTS A WESTERN CONSTRUCT? FROM THE CONFUCIUS PEACE PRIZE TO THE PRACTICE OF SUTTEE IN INDIA
Journal Title: The Journal of International Social Research - Year 2012, Vol 5, Issue 21
Abstract
Raimundo Pániker, a Hindu- Roman Catholic theologian and academic states in his paper, Is the Notion of Human Rights a Western Concept?, “Does another culture also have the notion of Human Rights? --assuming that such a notion is absolutely indispensable to guarantee human dignity. No question is neutral, for every question conditions its possible answers. . . Human rights may turn out to be a Trojan horse, surreptitiously introduced to other civilizations. . . Can democracy imposed and remain democratic?”(Panikkar, 1982: 238). Pániker argues the notion of Human rights is a western construct, non-universal and should be subjected or be malleable to the features of local culture (cultural relativism) or risk human rights being introduced like a Trojan horse, risking the survivability of local cultures (Panikkar and Panikkar, 1982: 247). In this paper I will argue while human rights are indeed a western concept, the adoption of human rights as a universal concept is a necessary one. I will base my reasoning upon the case study of the practice of Suttee in the Indian subcontinent.
Authors and Affiliations
Thomas NG
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP265539
- DOI -
- Views 134
- Downloads 0
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF SUBTITLING IN AUDIOVISUAL TRANSLATION
Subtitling is one of the most used methods in translating foreign films shown in movie theaters in Turkey. The other method, dubbing, is generally preferred when the film is for children. Subtitling and dubbing, two main...
ECONOMIC, ECOLOGICAL AND SOCIAL DIMENSIONS OF SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Sustainable development is an important area of study for many scientific disciplines since the 1980s, when the debate about the fight against environmental issues that arise as a result of people's interaction with the...
NEŞÂTÎ’NİN İMAM HÜSEYN MERSİYESİ
Bu çalışmada 17. yüzyıl şairlerinden Neşâtî Ahmed Dede’nin “Mersiyye Lî Hazret-i İmâm Hüseyn” isimli terkîb-i bendi tahlil edilmiştir. Mersiye’nin konusu, Hz.Hüseyn’in 10 Muharrem 61’de (10 Ekim 680)de Kerbelâ’da şehid e...
THE CITIZEN REPORT CARD AS A WAY OF STRENGTHENING SERVICE DELIVERY: A CASE STUDY FROM ANTALYA, TURKEY
A citizen report card (CRC) is deemed to be an advocacy tool to improve the quality of public services through rating them from a user perspective. In 2012, the Antalya City Council, together with the Antalya Governorate...
EDUCATION AND FILIAL NORMS: ADULT DAUGHTERS AND OLDER MOTHERS IN TURKEY
In the light of contemporary ageing societies, intergenerational solidarity is becoming more crucial for welfare states. Intergenerational solidarity is a multi-dimensional and multidirectional concept affected by variou...