At the source of American legal realism
Journal Title: Polish Law Review - Year 2017, Vol 3, Issue 1
Abstract
American legal realism is not very popular in the continental jurisprudence, strongly dominated by legal positivism. The purpose of the paper is to remind the characteristic features of that movement, as they are conceived nowadays. First and foremost it is an attempt at identification its socio-historical sources and intellectual climate which inspired its absolute precursor, justice Olivier Wendell Holmes. Several different characterisations and definitions are outlined, which are only partially overlapping. It seems that the realists have never constructed their own, consistent programme, but were much better at criticising legal positivism and natural law concepts. We may distinguish three generations of realists, who developed their ideas under the influence of two wars (American Civil War and First World War) and the rapidly changing economic and social environment. Holmes represented the first generation and used to be more a practising lawyer than a philosopher. His main thesis included in his papers, speeches and justice’s opinions are further discussed. Especially I emphasise his anti-formalism, pragmatism, instrumental approach to the law and his prediction ontology of law which are rooted in the evolutionary and historical thinking. Even though he preached against formal legal reasoning and legal positivism in general, in several cases he did not avoid applying those criticised legal methods, which gave rise to the unjustified claim, made by some contemporary philosophers, that legal realism was anchored in the positivists’ ontology.<br/><br/>
Authors and Affiliations
Marcin Gorazda
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP251320
- DOI -
- Views 135
- Downloads 0
Byt, powinność i informacja – perspektywy naturalistycznej metafizyki prawa
Nowoczesne koncepcje metafizyki prawa milcząco akceptują rozpad świata na sferę faktów (bytu, konkretów czasoprzestrzennych, stanów fizykalnych, sferę przedmiotową) i powinności (norm, idei, stanów mentalnych, sferę podm...
Prawne oraz pedagogiczne uwagi na temat Monitoringu Rzecznika Praw Dziecka: pt „Przemoc w wychowaniu”
Prawo oraz wychowanie to zjawiska, które nieustannie się przenikają. Z jednej strony w procesie wychowania w sposób nieunikniony operujemy pojęciami, praw, wolności oraz autonomii. Wychowanie ma skutkować ukształtowaniem...
The constitutional crisis in Poland as a negative model of Hans Kelsen’s constitutional judiciary idea
In the face of constitutional crisis in Poland, initiated in 2015 and ongoing to this day, it is essential for academics to describe legal events and rationales constituting the crisis using such measures so that issues...
Opinia o Nowelizacji - oddalamy się od Europy
Zamieszanie prawne jakie spowodowało polityczne zawirowania wokół wyboru sędziów Trybunału Konstytucyjnego trwa w Polsce już prawie rok. Niestety nadal nie widać finału sporu. W próbę jego rozwiązania zaangażowały się ni...
The impact of the WTO on the legal culture of Asian states
The World Trade Organization law, similarly to the former GATT 1947, was to a large extent prepared by the representatives of western countries. This fact has deep consequences for the mechanisms of functioning of this o...