CONTRASTING CASES AND THEIR IMPACT ON LEARNING: A REPLICATION OF A LEARNING STUDY CONFIRMING THE IMPACT OF CONTRASTS
Journal Title: Problems of Education in the 21st Century - Year 2009, Vol 10, Issue 1
Abstract
The present article describes how Swedish pupils in class 4 (nine to eleven years old) learn English as a second language. The study replicates a learning study carried out within the framework of a more extensive project known as “The Pedagogy of Learning”. The present study is aiming to find out if the results from one original learning study can be generalised to other teachers and pupils. The pupils participating in the presented study learn how to use “to have”. The original Learning Study Cycle (LSC) consisted of three lessons per cycle, each lesson carried out in different groups of pupils. The teachers focused on the critical aspects, i.e. the features which must be distinguished in order to understand a phenomenon. This process entailed investigating the contrasts between the specified learning outcome(s), i.e. the ability or knowledge targeted. The lessons were planned from a variation theory perspective. The LSC demonstrated that the use of contrast – applied in only one of the three lessons – between “to be” and “to have” had a positive effect on pupils’ generative learning, i.e. continued learning outside the classroom. In order to establish if the results of the present study are coincidental or repeatable the LSC was replicated. The first replicated study was conducted by a group of teachers with a good knowledge of variation theory. These teachers had previously applied the theory in mathematics lessons. A second replication was initiated by a group of teachers with no knowledge of variation theory. The results demonstrated that contrast is important for generative learning provided that teachers are able to focus on critical aspects and thereby elucidate contrast. In the group familiar with variation theory the results were similar to those of the original study, i.e. generative learning was promoted, while contrast had little effect on the pupils generative learning in the group of teachers who had no knowledge of variation theory. The study demonstrates that generative learning is dependent on teachers’ knowledge of how the critical aspects of the target knowledge should be presented to pupils. Such knowledge enables teachers to apply contrast as a means of developing pupils’ ability to distinguish qualitative differences. In this way, pupils continue to develop their knowledge beyond the classroom.
Authors and Affiliations
Mona Holmqvist, Jane Mattisson
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP34609
- DOI -
- Views 359
- Downloads 0
Differences between learning facts anD complex phenomena: a learning stuDy in history baseD on Variation theory
This study has been carried out as part of a project entitled “The Pedagogy of Learning” (Holmqvist, 2002) whose objective is to use theory and practice to extend our knowledge of learning and teaching. The study was i...
APACER: A six-stEP modEl foR tHE intRoduCtion of ComPutERsuPPoRtEd lAboRAtoRy ExERCisEs in biology tEACHing
This article describes a six-step approach used for the introduction of computer-supported laboratory exercises in Biology teaching. Following the model students will be guided from recognizing a problem question to th...
PROPOSIONAL COURSES OF TEACHER EDUCATION: ISSUES AND CHALLENGES
The research focuses on the reformulation of undergraduate courses in universities in the state of Parana, Brazil. The research problem arises in the context of reformulations in the courses of teacher formation, the u...
TEACHING COMPUTER SCIENCE & ENGINEERING THROUGH ROBOTICS: SCIENCE & ART FORM
Is the field of computer science and engineering a strict discipline or an art form? The answer is both. Computer science and engineering concepts are typically found almost exclusively in collegiate engineering and tech...
CLASSROOM CLIMATE AS A PART OF CONTEMPORARY DIDACTICAL APPROACHES
To achieve successful teaching in the 21st century school, teachers must change their didactical approaches in order to create a stimulating pro-activeness in a pleasant classroom climate for better development of studen...