EXPERT OPINION AS EVIDENCE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS
Journal Title: «Приватне та публічне право» - Year 2017, Vol 1, Issue
Abstract
This article is devoted to problems of forensic expert opinion consideration as evidence during the pre-trial investigation and the trial. This attempt is aimed to analyze the expert opinion as evidence, the source of the evidence, to establish common and different features between these concepts, which often are evaluated as identical by the scientists in the field of procedural law. Expert opinion in the article is seen as evidence together with other evidence, since it is not primary. It is based on previously acquired facts and information, but it is unique in its essence, it is author’s vision and he personally is responsible for it. The value of expert opinion is in line with other factual circumstances of the case. It is determined that the expert opinion is a detailed description of a forensic expert studies and conclusions made on the basis of their results, as well as grounded answers to the questions. It should be done only in the written form. The author made the first attempt in the science of criminal procedure and the law of evidence to classify it as evidence. For example, it is noted that the expert opinions depending on approval or denial of the fact that require confirmation using special knowledge can be positive or negative. In other cases, they may be defined as probable, or point to the impossibility of solving the issue. According to the source of obtaining information, expert opinion can be regarded as primary, as drawn up for the first time, and as a derivative, as derived from the previously obtained facts by the investigation or the court. Equivalence of both provisions does not, according to the author, allow classifying it by this provision. In relation to the subject of prosecution expert opinion may be guilty and acquittal, depending on the fact it proves. According to the findings of the expert the conclusion of the study may be of a categorical and probable character. In relation to the facts to be proved, expert opinions are divided into direct and adverse. Those that deny or confirm the circumstances to be proved are defined as direct. Others that are not unambiguous are defined as indirect. According to details the expert opinion is related to the document. According to the mechanism of formation it is drawn by a forensic expert personally, but the investigation concerns the facts that are not related to the forensic expert. The author proposed to consider the expert opinion as complex evidence; just as evidence and not as a source of evidence. It also has the features of secondary evidence, since it is not based on new information but on previously established. These provisions are relevant to the theory of the law of evidence.
Authors and Affiliations
А. В. Шульженко
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP444365
- DOI -
- Views 95
- Downloads 0
TAX ADMINISTRATION AS A SYSTEM-CREATING AND LEGAL INSTRUMENT OF TAXATION IN UKRAINE
The article analyzes the opinions of scientists about the definition of the notion “tax administration”, justifies the legal nature, the content and features of tax administration as a system-creating and legal instrumen...
PROBLEMATIC ISSUES OF THE JUDICIAL POWER REFORM IN UKRAINE
The purpose of the article is to identify the main directions of improving the administration of justice in Ukraine taking into account the requirements of international standards for the protection of human rights and i...
SOME ASPECTS OF RESPONSIBILITY FOR PARENTS FAILING TO COMPLY WITH ALIMENTARY OBLIGATIONS
Ukraine is a European leader in the number of divorces as a result of which the children are left to live with one parent. The parent who does not live with the child is obliged to provide the maintenance. But quite a nu...
LEGAL REGULATION OF STATE SUPERVISION AND CONTROL FOR THE EXERCISE OF LEGISLATION ON LABOR LAWS OF LABOR AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW: COMPARATIVE ASPECTS
Discussions regarding the legal nature of the legal regulation of state supervision and control over the observance of labor legislation call for the consideration of the issue of labor relations and administrative issue...
ACTUAL ISSUES OF IMPLEMENTATION ECONOMIC ACTIVITY IN THE AREA OF ANTI-TERRORIST OPERATION
In this article the question of conducting business activity in the ATO zone and carrying out economic relations with enterprises registered in the territory of the Russian Federation are investigated. The ways of minimi...