Human Rights, Religious Identity, and the Private-Public Distinction

Journal Title: The Journal of Human Rights - Year 2007, Vol 1, Issue 2

Abstract

It is thought that by respecting an adequately drawn private (or personal) sphere, political institutions can give sufficient freedom to people to develop their distinct cultural and religious identities without compromising human rights values. The public sphere is where rights are observed, the private is where rights claims have no role. However, the distinction between the private and the public sphere is a difficult one to draw. In this paper we argue that there is no pre-theoretical notion of the public and private, but rather that the boundaries between private and public are themselves sensitive to the moral theory of rights one adopts. So rather than rights being understood in terms of the public and the private, the public and private distinction should be understood in terms of rights. As evidence for the lack of an independent distinction we cite a study of cases in European courts, where the public-private distinction was paramount in adjudicating the rights of religious minorities. چکیده در این مقاله، تحلیلی از مسئلة اصلی نظریه و رویة قضایی حقوق بشر را بسط می‌دهیم. مشکل به برخورد با هویت دینی در دولت‌هایی مربوط می‌شود که مدعی دفاع از معیارهای حقوق بشر در اروپا هستند. این مشکل - به عنوان مثال - خود را در قالب ممنوعیت اعمال مذهبی خاصی نشان داده است که تصور می‌شود اصول مطابق با مبانی دولت در برخی از حکومت‌های اروپایی را نقض می‌کند. از جملة این اعمال مذهبی می‌توان به پوشیدن روسری و سایر موارد مذهبی توسط کسانی که وظایفی دولتی برعهده دارند (مانند کارمندان دولت و معلمین) یا کسانی که به اماکن عمومی وارد می‌شوند (مانند محصّلان مدارس و دانشگاه‌های دولتی)، اشاره کرد.

Authors and Affiliations

Saladin Meckled-Garcia, Basak Cali

Keywords

Related Articles

Solidarity; Syncretism of Peace and Friendship

Considered as a fundamental virtue in the classical political thought, “friendship” even outshined the other important virtues like “justice”. However, the emergence of modernity and the consequent epistemological ruptur...

The role of women in nation-building: rocking the boat at the risk of making it capsize?

I have been in exile for a long time, and I was amazed at the resilience, intelligence, strength and ability of the Afghan women that I met who came from inside the country and around the world. These women, I promise, c...

Right to Social Security in Human Rights Instruments and in International Labor Organization (with a glance at some Islamic Countries Practices)

The right to Social Security is one of the rights which appears in two important instruments of human rights—that is, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Th...

The spiritual crisis: Human Rights and Religion Political Theory of Human Rights

My intention in this research is to focus on the idea of spiritual crisis in human rights arena. The topic I shall be discussing concerns a basic set of issues dealing with the purpose of human rights, their moral found...

Freedom of Disassociation and Religious Communities: A Jewish Model for Associational Rights

"Freedom of association" as a right is a misnomer. Really, the right is about the "freedom of disassociation" and the right of one group to exclude individuals from the circle of its community or association. Granting th...

Download PDF file
  • EP ID EP302490
  • DOI -
  • Views 151
  • Downloads 0

How To Cite

Saladin Meckled-Garcia, Basak Cali (2007). Human Rights, Religious Identity, and the Private-Public Distinction. The Journal of Human Rights, 1(2), 55-66. https://www.europub.co.uk/articles/-A-302490