Importance and usefulness of separate opinion exposed on giving judgment
Journal Title: Revista Institutului Național al Justiției - Year 2016, Vol 38, Issue 3
Abstract
In this article, making a synthesis of judicial practice based on documentary material accumulated through my professional activity, we wanted to open a scientific discussion on the importance and usefulness of separate opinion exposed on giving judgment, considering that this institution of Criminal Procedural Law is an essential element in ensuring and promoting the independence of the judge in deliberations. The approach to the problem is flagged as relevant to realism, balance and importance of separate opinion on the fair settlement of the case, the aim being legal challenge and stimulate research of this topic for the benefit of jurisprudence and legislation. From this perspective, we suggest for reading and analysis considerations of an separate opinion in a decision of the court of appeal in a criminal case recently held. We also propose the modification of the content of Article 340, para. (3) of Criminal Procedural Code in the following formula: „If the decision is taken by the majority, the separate opinion of judge is attached and this will be mentioned in the enacting part of de decision”.
Authors and Affiliations
Sergiu Furdui
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP195302
- DOI -
- Views 117
- Downloads 0
The particularities of rising exception of tardiness in the civil process from Republic of Moldova
Judicial form is the most effective way to protect rights and interests in a democratic society. The holder of a subjective civil right must be able to request the help of the coercive force of the state in order to rest...
PREPARATION FOR JUDICIAL DEBATES OF THE CASES REGARDING THE CONTESTATION OF THE NOTARIAL BODY REFUSAL TO FULFILL NOTARIAL ACTS AND THE CASES ON THE VERIFICATION OF THE LEGALITY OF FULFILLED NOTARIAL ACTS
In this scientific and practical article the author conducted a study of main aspects of preparation of cases about appealing in the Administrative Court against notarial actions or refusal to make the same for judicial...
Determination of violent crimes in the Republic of Armenia
Features of determination of violent crimes in the Republic of Armenia are considered in this article. Powerful determinants of violence not only in Armenia, but practically in all countries are poverty and social-econom...
Special aspects of legal defense of activities of journalist in Ukraine
In the article the question of the legal basis of the professional journalist in Ukraine, analyzes the dynamics of the number of crimes committed against journalists and activities to enhance the protection of profession...
Civil society participation in protecting and monitoring the constitutional social rights’ observance
The article deals with the activities of non-governmental organizations, other representatives of the civil society of the Republic of Moldova in protecting and monitoring the observance of constitutional social human ri...