Leibniz’s well-founded fictions and their interpetations
Journal Title: Математичні Студії - Year 2018, Vol 49, Issue 2
Abstract
Leibniz used the term fiction in conjunction with infinitesimals. What kind of fictions they were exactly is a subject of scholarly dispute. The position of Bos and Mancosu contrasts with that of Ishiguro and Arthur. Leibniz's own views, expressed in his published articles and correspondence, led Bos to distinguish between two methods in Leibniz's work: (A) one exploiting classical `exhaustion' arguments, and (B) one exploiting inassignable infinitesimals together with a law of continuity. Of particular interest is evidence stemming from Leibniz's work Nouveaux Essais sur l'En- tendement Humain as well as from his correspondence with Arnauld, Bignon, Dagincourt, Des Bosses, and Varignon. A careful examination of the evidence leads us to the opposite conclusion from Arthur's. We analyze a hitherto unnoticed objection of Rolle's concerning the lack of justification for extending axioms and operations in geometry and analysis from the ordinary domain to that of infinitesimal calculus, and reactions to it by Saurin and Leibniz. A newly released 1705 manuscript by Leibniz (Puisque des personnes. . . ) currently in the process of digitalisation, sheds light on the nature of Leibnizian inassignable infinitesimals. In a pair of 1695 texts Leibniz made it clear that his incomparable magnitudes violate Euclid's Definition V.4, a.k.a. the Archimedean property, corroborating the non-Archimedean construal of the Leibnizian calculus.
Authors and Affiliations
J. Bair, P. Blaszczyk, R. Ely, M. G. Katz
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP411804
- DOI 10.15330/ms.49.2.186-224
- Views 68
- Downloads 0
Hilbert transform on W1σ
We obtain a boundedness criterion for the Hilbert transform on the Paley-Wiener space in the terms of decomposition. Since we have a simple method of evaluation of the Hilbert transform.
Sequential coarse structures of topological groups
We endow a topological group (G,τ) with a coarse structure defined by the smallest group ideal Sτ on G containing all converging sequences and denote the obtained coarse group by (G,Sτ). If G is discrete, then (G,Sτ) is...
Quantitative version of the Bishop-Phelps-Bollobas theorem for operators with values in a space with the property β
The Bishop-Phelps-Bollobas property for operators deals with simultaneous approximation of an operator T and a vector x at which T:X→Y nearly attains its norm by an operator F and a vector z, respectively, such that F at...
Homomorphisms between rings with infinitesimals and infinitesimal comparisons
We examine an argument of Reeder suggesting that the nilpotent infinitesimals in Paolo Giordano's ring extension of the real numbers ∙R are smaller than any infinitesimal hyperreal number of Abraham Robinson's nonstandar...
The best approximations and widths of the classes of periodical functions of one and several variables in the space B∞,1
We obtained exact-order estimates of the best approximations of classes BΩ∞,θ of periodic functions of many variables and for classes Bωp,θ,1≤p≤∞ of functions of one variable by trigonometric polynomials with correspondi...