Mourning, Memorials, and Religion: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on the Park51 Controversy
Journal Title: Religions - Year 2011, Vol 2, Issue 2
Abstract
This article summarizes a version of the “mourning religion” thesis—derived from the work of Peter Homans and further developed and advanced by William Parsons, Diane Jonte-Pace, and Susan Henking—and then demonstrates how this thesis can shed light on the Park51 controversy. We argue that the Park51 controversy represents a case of incomplete cultural mourning of an aspect of American civil religion that manifests itself in melancholic rage by means of protests, threats to burn the Qur’an (as well as actual burnings of the Qur’an), and vandalism of mosques around the United States. We explore various losses—military, economic, and symbolic—and note that these losses remain ambiguous, therefore preventing closure and productive mourning. The fact that a permanent memorial still has not been built at Ground Zero reflects, and perhaps exacerbates, this incomplete cultural mourning. Also, the fact that Freedom Tower, the building to replace the Twin Towers, is to be 1776 feet tall reflects that the losses related to 9/11 are connected to American civil religion, as 1776 is a sacred year in American history. Setting aside the ethics and the politics related to this controversy, we attempt here to understand this controversy from a psychoanalytic perspective.
Authors and Affiliations
Nathan Carlin and Heba Khan
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP25189
- DOI https://doi.org/10.3390/rel2020114
- Views 393
- Downloads 15
History, Hysteria, and Hype: Government Contracting with Faith-Based Social Service Agencies
In light of the adoption of the Charitable Choice Provision of the Welfare Reform Bill and the creation of White House Offices on faith based initiatives this article examines the history of government contracting with...
‘Something Drew Me In’: The Professional and Personal Impact of Working with Spirituality in Addiction Recovery
This research addresses the impact of working with spirituality from the perspective of the addiction worker with five separate interviews conducted with people who have been working in the area of addiction for ten ye...
The Empire in the Provinces: The Case of Carinthia
This article examines the legacy of the Habsburg Monarchy in the First Austrian Republic, both in the capital, Vienna, and in the province of Carinthia. It concludes that Social Democracy, often cited as one of the six...
Syariah as Heterotopia: Responses from Muslim Women in Aceh, Indonesia
In this paper, I argue that the implementation of syariah is best understood as a heterotopia by women in Aceh, Indonesia. The current debates over the role of syariah for women in Acehnese society focus on either a se...
Development and Application of a Spiritual Well-Being Questionnaire Called SHALOM
The Four Domains Model of Spiritual Health and Well-Being was used as the theoretical base for the development of several spiritual well-being questionnaires, with progressive fine-tuning leading to the Spiritual Healt...