Patients who seek traditional magico-religious treatments: Are they different from patients who seek medical treatments? A case-control study
Journal Title: Telangana Journal of Psychiatry - Year 2016, Vol 2, Issue 2
Abstract
Introduction: A patient’s decision to seek help for mental health symptoms (and from who) depends on a number of socio-demographic and illness related factors, as well as accessibility and affordability of care. Traditionally magico-religious healers have constituted an important source of health-care for a significant proportion of mentally ill patients in India. The concern however, is that these consultations may also delay patients en route their pathway to medical or psychiatric care- thus potentially adding to the duration of untreated illness and associated poor outcomes. Aims: The present study aimed to examine whether patients who seek traditional magico-religious treatments were different from those who seek medical or mental health care for their symptoms. Methodology: Ninety-one patients were recruited from the Outpatient and emergency departments of the Institute of Medical Psychology, Asha hospital in Hyderabad, Telangana. After gaining informed consent, carers (key informants) for these patients were interviewed to enquire about the patient’s first and subsequent care contacts, as well as for a number of background socio-demographic and illness details. Subjects whose first contact was with a traditional magico-religious healer were compared with subjects who sought help from a medical or mental health professional (psychiatrist/ physician/ registered or unregistered medical practitioner/ medical specialist/ community nurse) for their symptoms. Results: Thirty three (36.3%) of the subjects had sought care from magico-religious healers in the first instance. The rest (63.7%) consulted various other healthcare providers like medical practitioners, psychiatrists, medical specialists like neurologists, community nurses/ social workers, etc. Subjects who sought care from magico-religious healers were similar to those did not, with respect to their age, sex-distribution, residence, social status and incomes, but the latter group was more educated than the former (p<0.05). The groups did not differ with respect to their diagnostic distribution or the duration of untreated illness. However, the magico-religious treatment subjects sought care (from the magico-religious healer) substantially sooner than those who sought care from elsewhere. They also had more health-care contacts than the non-magico-religious treatment group (p<0.05), despite the duration of untreated illness being comparable between the two groups. Discussion and Implications: Magico-religious healers constitute an important health-care contact point for patients who develop mental health symptoms. This study did not identify any specific socio-demographic profile of patients who consult magico-religious healers in the first instance. They were however, less educated than patients who seek health-care from alternative sources. We also could not identify any specific diagnostic characteristics of patients who consult magico-religious healers. Although these patients do have more health-care contacts before they seek psychiatric care and treatment, this did not delay their eventual psychiatric treatment (as compared to patients who did not seek magico-religious treatments). This study has implications for the development of mental health services. Training and awareness creation amongst patients as well as locally identified magico-religious healers may help to shorten the duration of untreated illness. Maintenance of a registry of locally practicing magico-religious healers, regular training/ exchange of information, and active liaison with local psychiatric services may help in improving mental health care. This is probably especially relevant in the current context of scarce governmental resources.
Authors and Affiliations
Aparna B, Duddu V, Prasad Rao G
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP243161
- DOI -
- Views 98
- Downloads 0
Awareness and Attitude towards Law pertaining to Suicide in Suicide attempters' and their Families in Rural South-India
ntroduction: An attempt to commit suicide has been decriminalised in several countries. However, India remains on the brink of the act of suicide being decriminalised as the new Health Care Bill may soon be realised. As...
Plica Neuropathica - a case report
Plica Neuropathica (Polonica) is a condition where the scalp hair in a localized area is compacted into irregularly twisted, irreversibly entangled plaits. It was prevalent in Poland in the 19th century, hence the name p...
Attitudes towards psychiatry as a prospective career among medical interns
Introduction In India there is a great shortage of psychiatrists unable to respond to the demands of providing good quality mental health care More women worldwide are taking up psychiatry as a career Medical interns are...
Factors associated with medical comorbid conditions in alcohol use disorders-preliminary findings from a general hospital setting in Bangalore, South India.
Background: Alcohol use disorders contribute significantly to global morbidity and mortality. Alcohol use disorders are also associated with presence of comorbid psychiatric as well as medical conditions. There is a need...
Under reporting of child sexual abuse- The barriers guarding the silence
Underreporting of Child Sexual Abuse CSA is rampant in India despite which India has the highest number of CSA cases in the world the ramifications of which are enormous Other than the obvious reasons of stigma and fear...