Philosophizing Tasawwuf: The Postmodern Cult of Sufism
Journal Title: Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization (JITC) - Year 2011, Vol 1, Issue 0
Abstract
The paper is a critical study of some relatively recent Western approaches to tasawwuf. These so-called post-structuralist approaches, the deconstructionist being chief among them, seem to extend the earlier orientalist attempts, as that of Henry Corbin, Reynolds Nicholson or Pervez Morevidge, of philosophizing tasawwuf, thus turning it into one among various other ‗isms‘ conveniently available to the Western critical understanding. Reviewing Ian Almond‘s Deconstruction and Sufism and The New Orientalists, the paper argues that in their preoccupation with tracing apparent affinities between the deconstructive/ post-structuralist and the Sufi positions on the socalled ‗metaphysics of presence‘, what such studies often overlook is the epistemological difference between these two discourses. It remains a matter of some detailed discussion, which the paper does propose to attempt, to see that these recent critical approaches in the West, despite their avowed project of announcing the demise of philosophy, still somehow remain essentially complicit with the tradition of thought they look to dismantle.
Authors and Affiliations
Iftikhar Shafi
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP472709
- DOI 10.32350/jitc.11.01
- Views 192
- Downloads 0
Islamic Tradition and its Defining Characteristics
Tradition conveys the meanings of connectedness to past and transmission of knowledge, practice, laws, and many other elements of both an oral and written nature. “Islamic Tradition” is no different from the general defi...
Understanding Peace and Nonviolence in Islam with Maulānā Wahīduddīn Khān
Islam is the religion of peace; rather it is the very embodiment of it. The very name ‘Islam’ is derived from the Arabic trilateral root s.l.m, which primarily denotes peace. The related term ‘Īmān’ signifies ‘giving pea...
Al-Jami‘al-‘Atiq, the Oldest Mosque in Jidda
Old Jidda, which is now a neighbourhood within the Hijazi City Jidda, is a square kilometer area with properties built during different time periods. AlJami‘ al-‘Atiq literally means the old mosque. It is also known as a...
Historicizing Islam: Re-thinking tolerance
In spite of all efforts to paint a black portrait of Islam and to introduce it as a hostile and intolerant creed, Islamic civilization played a major role in shaping global civilization. Prominent Muslim scholars and int...
Romancing the Sufi: Persian Sufi Poetry under the Western Gaze
The paper presents an argument against the problematic comparison of the Sufi poetry with Romanticism that is found among some of the most noted comparatists. It emphasizes the need to put both discourses within their co...