Religious discourse and Philosophy Ibn Rusd and Thomas Aquinas
Journal Title: Poznańskie Studia Teologiczne - Year 2015, Vol 29, Issue
Abstract
The article by Joseph Ellul OP analyses similarities and differences in the philosophical approach of Ibn Rušd and St. Thomas Aquinas. For the Muslim philosopher, religion appealed to the masses by applying symbols, imagery and laws, whereas philosophy arrived at the truths of revealed Law through demonstration. He goes to great lengths in order to establish the existence of harmony between philosophy and religion, but he appears to take it in the sense of conformity of religion to the requirements of rational discourse, particularly in his discussion of the literal and the allegorical interpretation of the Qur’ân. For Thomas Aquinas revealed truth, that is to say the truth of the Christian faith, lies beyond reason, but the latter cannot be opposed to the former, since what nature endows cannot be opposed to supernatural gift. The exercise of reason is instrumental in order to clarify, corroborate and defend the truths of the Christian faith. Consequently, reason should be applied in order to prove that what adversaries are stating about the Christian faith is false. Although the realm of reason is not coextensive with that of faith, this by no means should imply that they are mutually exclusive or contradictory. As Aquinas points out, the philosopher considers creatures as they are, whereas the believer views them in their relation to God. Aquinas’s intellectual investigations allowed him to bridge the divide that arose in encounters with members of non-Christian religions in the common pursuit of truth. His works are a living testimony to the encounter between Christian thought and Islamic philosophy inspired by both the Peripatetics and the Neoplatonists together with the indirect contribution of Muslim theological thought.
Authors and Affiliations
Joseph Ellul
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP369304
- DOI 10.14746/pst.2015.29.3
- Views 134
- Downloads 0
Leszek Kołakowski, Jezus ośmieszony. Esej apologetyczny i sceptyczny, tłum. Dorota Zańko, Kraków: Znak 2014, ss. 137.
Leszek Kołakowski, Jezus ośmieszony. Esej apologetyczny i sceptyczny, tłum. Dorota Zańko, Kraków: Znak 2014, ss. 137.
Kairos der Barmherzigkeit. Barmherzigkeit als Prinzip einer missionarischen Seelsorge
The pastoral care of the church needs a paradigm, on which it can build its practice. This paradigm must take signs of the contemporary times into account. The message of mercy was crucial for the pontificates of John XX...
Formacja katechetów w aspekcie kanonicznym
The article first presents the need and necessity of the formation of catechists. Then it shows the issue of the subject responsible for the preparation of catechists. There is also a lengthy discussion of the character...
Les Juifs vus par un prêtre français en exil: l’antijudaïsme dans les Mémoires de l’abbé Pochard (1796-1830)
The article is an attempt to show the leading elements of the attitude towards Jews, the attitude of Father Claude-Antoine Pochard (1766-1833), tutor in the family of a Gniezno governor Joseph Skórzewski. Numerous trips...
Napięcie między wyborem bogactwa lub ubóstwa w perspektywie królestwa Bożego (Łk 18, 18-30)
In Gospel of Luke there are a number of critical statements about rich people. The third Evangelist wrote down, for example: [God] sent the rich away with empty hands (Lk 1: 53). But how terrible for you who are rich now...