Sprawiedliwość prawnomaterialna a proceduralna – kilka uwag na temat napięć między różnymi postaciami sprawiedliwości w prawie cywilnym
Journal Title: Studia Iuridica - Year 2017, Vol 70, Issue
Abstract
The article analyzes the concept of justice in both procedural and substantive aspects of civil law, with regards to John Rawls’ notion of “procedural justice”. The basic problem of the article is the question if each outcome of a fair procedure is just by the token of the fairness of the procedure. The author argues that such a standpoint, claiming that the procedure itself creates a just decision, will be incompatible with Article 45 paragraph 1 of the Polish Constitution. This paragraph grants the right to just adjudicature, which takes into account the whole substantive law. There are areas in law where conflicts between the procedural and the substantive justice are possible. Such an area is the adversary trial proceedings and evidentiary proceedings. The Court of Justice of the European Union emphasizes that there are such groups of legal entities (eg. consumers), for which it is necessary to regard ex officio all of facts pointing to the unjust treatment of consumer. The similar point of view was expressed by the Supreme Court of Poland. The Supreme Court of Poland allowed an evaluation of a claim which includes principles of justice, even if the defendant doesn’t take any position. This belief agrees with the standpoint of E. Waśkowski, who emphasized that the sentence should be “rightful”.<br/><br/>
Authors and Affiliations
Krzysztof Kurosz
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP232591
- DOI 10.5604/01.3001.0010.5645
- Views 92
- Downloads 0
History of the Center for American Law Studies
-<br/><br/>
Warsaw Rising: The Warsaw Stock Exchange a Successful Model for Transition Economies
Wymiana papierów wartościowych w warunkach gospodarki przejściowej zwykle napotyka na różne wyzwania. Trudności te są częściowo spowodowane słabym lub w ogóle nieistniejącym prawem papierów wartościowych. Warszawska Gieł...
Ograniczenie handlu w niedziele – przewidywanie skutków regulacji czy wróżenie z fusów?
This article is devoted to the issue of new Polish regulations introducing the principle of prohibiting trade on Sundays. As is clear from the justification of the Act, the argument for the provisions on the prohibition...
Extended Confiscation of a Material Benefit in Polish Criminal Law
On 23 March 2017 the Sejm (the lower chamber of the Polish Parliament) passed the Act on Amending the Criminal Code and Numerous Other Acts23. In the reasons appended to the draft bill it was asserted that the law intend...
Odpowiedzialność odszkodowawcza w ramach ujemnego interesu umowy
This article is discussing certain issues concerning the liability within the reliance interest under modern Polish civil law having as a background and a starting point Prof. Czachórski’s considerations over the idea of...