Taxonomy Construction and the Normative Turn in Religious Studies
Journal Title: Religions - Year 2017, Vol 8, Issue 12
Abstract
Jonathan Z. Smith contends that a taxonomic agenda underlies the study of religion. Before Smith, structuralist scholars saw it as their task to uncover the roots of human taxonomic arrangements that present themselves as natural. Drawing somewhat anachronistically on Smith’s taxonomic model, I argue that underlying investigative categories posed by structural anthropologists are operative strategies of subjective value and valuation. I employ Smith to amend structuralist classificatory paradigms and to speak to questions of normativity, values, and concealed agendas in the contemporary study of religion. Smith’s comparative program serves as a fertile territory of encounter between divergent religious studies subfields. In short, I argue that although the normative turn in religious studies has generally succeeded in deconstructing appeals to scholarly objectivity, it faces challenges along other parameters.
Authors and Affiliations
Travis Warren Cooper
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP25862
- DOI https://doi.org/10.3390/rel8120270
- Views 289
- Downloads 10
Naturalism, Normativity, and the Study of Religion
This article repudiates the common view that the study of religion, in order to qualify as academic, must be descriptively neutral and naturalistic rather than normative or prescriptive. Following philosophers like Joh...
Transcending Gender: Female Non-Buddhists’ Experiences of the Vipassana¯ Meditation Retreat
Female non-Buddhists have been writing detailed descriptions of their personal experiences in vipassana¯ meditation retreats since the 1960s. These memoirists relate to the English-speaking world their experience of th...
Buddhist Ritual from Syntax to Cognition: Insight Meditation and Homa
The concept of “ritual syntax” is developed by relating it to cognitive studies of ritual, providing a fuller theoretical basis. Developing theoretical grounding requires differentiating between the members of five pai...
John Muir and “Godful” Nature
John Muir, America‘s most influential conservationist, held a special view of Nature, one that treated Nature as ―Godful‖ and ―unredeemed‖ because, unlike humankind, Nature has not ―fallen‖. It is a view that asks us t...
What Are the “Long Nostrils” of YHWH?
The mention of YHWH’s “nostrils” (ʾapayīm) in the Bible is classically interpreted as a metonymy of the face and/or a metaphor for anger. The reference to their length and even to their elongation, however, rules out any...