The Election of Lay Judges and the Principle of Participation by Citizenry in the Administration of Criminal Justice
Journal Title: Białostockie Studia Prawnicze - Year 2016, Vol 0, Issue 20
Abstract
Participation in the administration of justice not only by professionals, but also by representatives of the citizenry, is one of important manifestations of contemporary modern democratic states. In recent years, one can notice not only a reduction in the catalogue of cases involving lay judges, but also a tendency to introduce restrictions on the right to stand as a lay judge (e.g. the requirement of completion of at least secondary education, adequate health, non-performing this function by a councilor of a municipality, county or province) as well as to regulate the electoral process more precisely (e.g. explicit exclusion of political parties from proposing candidates for lay judge appointments, raising the amount of citizens fi ling candidacy from 25 to 50, defi ning documents that must be attached to the application for a lay judgepost). Th e current system of election of lay judges in Poland is a legacy of communism, its principles founded in the 50s and 60s of the twentieth-century. Objections to the current selection system provoke proposals for making amendments. At least four possible ways of selecting lay judges can be proposed: general elections, drawing from among members of the local community, selection by competent courts or the introduction of a lay judgeexamination. Each of the abovementioned options presents advantages and disadvantages. Perhaps it is worth considering complementing the current electoral process with the ability to nominate candidates as lay judges from among members of the academic community, or possibly other persons enjoying the respect of society by the senates of universities, which should serve to increase the authority and competence of candidates insofar that in essence it constitutes a guarantee of their quality.
Authors and Affiliations
Dariusz Kużelewski
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP342935
- DOI 10.15290/bsp.2016.20A.11
- Views 59
- Downloads 0
Conclusions and Recommendations (Not Only) De Lege Ferenda Aft er the Crisis in the Polish Local Elections of 2014
Th e last local elections in Poland took place on 16th November 2014. Th e election ended in crisis due to collapse of the electronic system supporting the election. In this article the author claims that the crisis did...
Dylematy regulacji dziedziczenia ustawowego dzieci małżonka spadkodawcy (art. 9341 kc.)
Th e circle of statutory heirs cannot be accidental. Th e inclusion into Polish law of children of the deceased’s spouse to this circle is associated with the concept of the legislator to establish a wide range of potent...
Justifi cation of Judgments of the Advocacy Disciplinary Tribunal
Th e subject of this article is jurisdiction of decisions of the Advocacy Disciplinary Tribunal. Th e author focuses on the independence of the Law on Advocates and the Criminal Practice Rules. Appropriate application of...
Energy Poverty as a European Union and Polish Legal Issue
The aim of this paper is to answer the question of whether energy poverty prevention is a type of “patched” style of Europeanisation. The descriptive section accompanying the presented research identifi es the basic lega...
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) – Th e EU Law Strengthening the Information Society in Poland
The purpose of this paper is to illustrate how the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), now implemented in the Polish legal system, strengthens protection in the collection, processing, storage and transfer of digi...