UNCERTAINTIES OF ESTIMATING A TOWN’S CARBON FOOTPRINT– CASE STUDY EL GOUNA, EGYPT
Journal Title: Civil and Environmental Engineering Reports - Year 2019, Vol 1, Issue 29
Abstract
Carbon accounting has become a valuable tool for expressing the fossil energy demand of products, organizational entities, or entire countries. About a decade ago, cities also began accounting their carbon emissions. The first major city to do so was London in 2009, stating a carbon footprint of 4.84 tCO2eq/(year*capita) for 2008. Nowadays, multiple rankings compare the carbon emissions of cities. For example, the Urban Land Magazine lists São Paulo as the city with the world’s lowest carbon emissions (1.4 CO2eq/(year*capita)). Such listings typically present the depicted emission values as scientifically indisputable numbers. However, a closer look at the applied methodology frequently reveals a wide range of implicit, often undisclosed assumptions at the foundation of the calculations. This paper analyses the uncertainties of carbon accounting on the city scale, using the example of the Red Sea resort town of El Gouna. The estimated value of El Gouna’s carbon footprint for the year 2014 is 14.3 tCO2eq/(year*capita). Third Scope emissions constitute the majority of El Gouna’s carbon footprint. Varying their underlying assumptions only slightly can lead to alterations of the results of more than 50%, questioning the robustness of the findings. To increase the robustness and the comparability of carbon accounting across cities, this paper suggests emphasizing Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions, while limiting the role of Scope 3 emissions<br/><br/>
Authors and Affiliations
Christoph BANHARDT, Felix HARTENSTEIN
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP519319
- DOI 10.2478/ceer-2019-0003
- Views 80
- Downloads 0
ROAD INVESTMENT DESIGN IN AREAS PROTECTED BY THE MONUMENTS CONSERVATOR
Design works on road construction plans for areas protected by conservation require a proper preparation, especially in terms of formality, which has been described in this paper. One has shown the various methods of con...
ADAPTATION OF FORGOTTEN BUILDINGS THE EXAMPLE OF THE RUINS OF THE KOŚCIELEC PROTESTANT CHURCH IN PIASKI
Small towns in the Lublin Province are abundant with buildings possessed of outstanding historical and architectural values, representing the culture of past generations. Piaski, about 30 km east of Lublin, also boasts s...
PRELIMINARY ANALYSIS OF THE ALUMINIUM-TIMBER COMPOSITE BEAMS
This paper presents a new type of composite structures - aluminium-timber beams. These structures have an advantage over other existing composite structures, because they are lighter. However, their application may be li...
AIDED PHYTOSTABILIZATION OF COPPER CONTAMINATED SOILS WITH L. PERENNE AND MINERAL SORBENTS AS SOIL AMENDMENTS
The present study was designed to assess phytostabilization strategies for the treatment of soil co-contaminated by increasing levels of copper with the application mineral amendments (chalcedonite, zeolite, dolomite). F...
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) in gravity-operated and surface water from areas located nearby coking plant in Dąbrowa Górnicza (Upper Silesia region, Poland)
The paper presents the results of five PAHs contents determination in the surface and gravity-operated water. The samples of gravity-operated water were taken quarterly in 2009 from collectors put in fifteen points in ar...