Internal and External Limits of the Principle of Consistent Interpretation of Domestic Law with the Directives of the European Union and Th eir Relevance for the Adjudication of the Administrative Courts
Journal Title: Białostockie Studia Prawnicze - Year 2018, Vol 0, Issue 23
Abstract
Th is article examines the issues of external and internal limits of the consistent interpretation of the domestic law with the EU directives in the context of verifi cation adjudication of the administrative courts. Th e external limits of the pro-directive interpretation are derived from the EU law and the case-law of the Court of Justice of the EU. Th e limits of the pro-directive interpretation can as well be derived from the domestic law of the member states (the internal limits). Th is kind of limitations is strictly connected with domestic limits of the judicial interpretation. In the considerations it is argued that the pro-directive interpretation which goes beyond the literal meaning of domestic provisions could not be treated as being contrary to the domestic law. In the case-law of administrative courts the necessity of functional, purposive and axiological meaning of the contra legem limit is especially signifi cant. It is justifi ed to state that consistent interpretation must embrace operations of interpretation secundum legem and praeter legem. Therefore, the domestic contra legem limit is shaped and modifi ed by the EU rules of interpretation.
Authors and Affiliations
Marcin Kamiński
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP520916
- DOI 10.15290/bsp.2018.23.02.01
- Views 49
- Downloads 0
Glosa do wyroku Sądu Najwyższego z dnia 13 kwietnia 2016 r., II KK 304/15
Rozpowszechnianie wizerunku stanowiące znamię przestępstwa z art. 191a kk. w praktyce następuje wyłącznie za pomocą mediów elektronicznych, co samo w sobie w najmniejszym stopniu nie obniża stopnia szkodliwości społeczne...
The Fragility of a Culture of Lawfulness
Th e concept of a culture of lawfulness is appealing for its aspirational and open-ended nature. However, the concept still has to prove itself as a concrete basis for action. Th e article argues that the practical value...
Tradycyjne paradygmaty prawa rodzinnego w dobie rewolucji biotechnologicznej
Th e present paper emphasizes the need for changes in traditional paradigms of family law, which becomes even more indispensable in the context of the globalization process, cultural diff usion and biotechnological devel...
Commentary on the Judgment of the Court of Appeal in Katowice of 11 September 2015, V Aca 109/15
The interpretation of Article 13 § 1 of the Civil Code2 has to be made in the spirit of Article 30 of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland stipulating that the inherent and inalienable dignity of the person shall c...
Th e Participation of the Social Factor in the Judiciary from a Constitutional Perspective
Th e article presents the issue of social factor in the administration of justice from the perspective of constitutional rules. Th e aim of these considerations is to analyze the issue of limitation of the participation...